My first .357 revolver was the 66-8, and honestly I just didn't like it. I'm in the market for a solid revolver and I've been bouncing between these two for quite some time. Thirty years on and a good used Security Six can be had in the lower $300 price range. Smith will have a better trigger, although the ruger is serviceable and will get better with use. 21 … It's the pinnacle of the fighting revolver before that category went the way of carbureted engines. In the early 1970s, when the double-action revolver was still the preference of most US law enforcement agencies, Ruger did not have a weapon to compete for this market, nor for civilian home protection users. Compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger LCR and Smith & Wesson Model 66 Combat Magnum This is a table top review and comparison of the Smith & Wesson Model 686, Ruger GP100 and the Taurus Model 627 Tracker. Two of the newest five-shot, medium-framed .44s—the Ruger GP100 and the Smith & Wesson Model 69—duke it out. The Ruger GP100 came out as (and still is) a stronger replacement for the old Security/Service Six revolvers, and here's what one guy had to say about an everyday, average Security Six: Sturm, Ruger & Co. has always been a bit of a dichotomy of a gun company. 100.00 € Ajouter au panier. I want a … Press J to jump to the feed. It probably will outlive me many times over. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. My collection is in sore need of a full-sized wheelgun in .357 Magnum. It probably will outlive me many times over. These are all 357 Magnum revolvers. The frame, cylinder release, sideplate, and crane arrangement are unmistakably S&W. While doing so however, they have embraced neo-classic aesthetics in their arms; examples include the their Blackhawk single-action revolvers, the M77 bolt action and No. It's come down to an S&W 66 and the Ruger GP100. I've owned and own both SW and Ruger revolvers and heads up the SW's are more accurate, better made, with vastly better triggers IMO. Close. Hopefully some folks out there have tried out the new Ruger GP100 22. razorback2003, Jan 21, 2016 … By Garrett Lucas. However, and this is the real reason why these guns are a solid buy, they will simply out last any other DA revolver over thousands of Magnum rounds. But pray you never have to shoot a .357 indoors. They are also usually razor-edged at the rear of the cylinder, requiring a light chamfer to ease the use of speedloaders. I always had Ruger 357's in magnum revolvers but wanted to buy a S&W based on the overwhelming comments about the better DA & SA. 5 years ago | 118 views. If you're going to shoot 357 with an regularity, the GP100. I'm going to go against the grain and suggest the 66. The ruger is built like a tank, but the 66 is the stainless "combat magnum." The GP100 with a Wolf Spring kit has an awesome trigger. Answer Save. We compare the Ruger GP 100 Match Champion to the Smith and Wesson 686. With the 686 i'll have a thinner frame along with the unsightly interior lock, however i'm a huge fan of smiths and the quality of their firearms. 1 Posts . A prior owner had taken the factory walnut “target” stocks and cut finger-grooves into their front and reduced their overall girth, making them suitable for smaller hands, but very slippery with the not-inconsiderable recoil of a full-house .357 round. Have owned GP100s in 4", 5" and 6". With the Match Champion Ruger dressed to the nines, in terms of features, does it finally dethrone Smith & Wesson as the king of revolvers? I had a 6" full under lug gp100 until I sold it to a family member. I will probably have to fit other stocks affording me a more secure grip, as it squirms beyond my ability to hold it consistently. It was the first revolver I ever fired. Liberty is a well-armed lamb contesting the vote. - Theodore Roosevelt. Log in sign up. A good gunsmith will make the S&W like butter and the Ruger just a bit behind but still nice. Voncile Harwood. I like the classic lines of the Smith K-frame and the trigger is so smooth. Stronger build, better customer service, better overall quality, a no brainer in my opinion. Single action: The Ruger is much improved but the Smith and Wesson is like glass. That thing is gorgeous. Takes too much wasted motion and effort to open quickly. I was comparing the GP-100 against the S&W 686 and the Taurus model 66. Posted by 3 years ago. Get the GP100. Sarge01 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Join Date: Jan 2010; Posts: 4346; Share Tweet #2. If I had to do it again, I'd go for the 4" version balance wise. All three nice revolvers. Ruger GP100. While this added to the cost of production, it means that the finished arm generally needs no trigger action job to make the stroke smooth from front to back. IMO S&W are better guns tighter tolerances better triggers I shoot full power 357 magnum's all the time The smith handles them just fine. User account menu. Compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger SP101 2.25" and Smith & Wesson Model 66 Combat Magnum Press J to jump to the feed. It probably will outlive me many times over. I can't decide which one to get gentleman; the Smith and Wesson 686 is about $600 and the Ruger GP100 is about 520. Colt’s hand fitting and S&W’s selective-assembly methods meant that revolvers were fitted to the dimensional accuracy of the trigger and hammer pin locations on the frame. Compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger GP100 4.2" and Smith & Wesson Model 66 Combat Magnum Keith and Skelton were also involved in the development of the 41 Magnum for law enforcement and hunting. 1:45. Sturm Ruger’s answer to the Smith & Wesson 686, the Ruger GP100 was introduced in the early 1990s. I noticed though, in the description for the Ruger, that they talk about their solid one piece frame. Smith and Wesson 686 vs. Ruger GP100 357? Réf : LPATXT0407 en stock. I have owned both the model 66-8 and a gp100. when I go hunting. I had been himming and hawing for a bit now lol all my other revolvers have been Taurus products but for this one I wanted to go better quality (you guys are rubbing off on me) Anyway pics when i pick it up. Question. They use the most modern of manufacturing methods, that of precision investment casting, much as would a jeweler or dental lab, to provide a near-final-sized raw part which thus requires a minimum of machining to become a completed arm. While the Smith & Wesson Model 610 and Ruger GP100 Match Champion are similar, they’re quite different 10mm revolvers. I've narrowed it down to the 686 vs GP100. 7. His other 4" and my 2.5" have never had any problems though. A forum community dedicated to Springfield Armory XD and XD-M series firearm owners and enthusiasts. I wouldn't want to shoot hundreds of rounds of magnums out of either gun (low fun factor IMO), but the SW will be plenty strong enough for occasional practice with full magnum loads, lots of practice with 38 special loads, and carrying for defense with full magnums. Archived . Otherwise ouch, baby. The 686 is mostly a refinement of the S&W’s iconic revolver pedigree, established with their K/L frame revolvers. I just hope other people got one better finished than mine was. between the Ruger GP100 and and S&W; 686 revolver (both chambered in .357 mag), which is the better deal? Recently went thru a similar situation, S&W vs Ruger.. Only when the trigger was fully-depressed in a firing stroke would the transfer bar rise and allow hammer to strike it and “transfer” that impact to the rear of the firing pin, discharging the chambered round. It'll outlive your grandkids, and easy to strip. Theyre both good guns but the trigger on S&Ws is way better. My Security Six kicks ass. Ruger chambers are usually a bit oversized, easing extraction when dirty, if compromising case life somewhat. In this instance, the L frame of the 686 denotes a medium-large frame, and is typical of modern, fullsize .357 Magnum offerings from Smith & Wesson. Report. 7. Archived. I have the 6" gp100 and I love it. Kind of depends on what you'll use it for. The GP100 is regarded as the strongest double action .357 magnum made, right up there with the smith N frame. Keith and Phil Sharpe were much more involved with the development of the 357 Magnum which was a pet project of Doug Wesson. Shooting .357 out of it felt very mild and controllable. It’s a toss up and the differences are minimal but Rugers are cast steel while S&W are forged steeel. The S&W is larger and heavier, making it more suitable for outdoor carry and a better choice for higher-pressure loads. If I had to go with a large revolver for a survival situation, the GP100 would be my choice. If one bought a Security Six, one could expect a lifetime of full use and still be able to hand it to one’s children with nary a problem. Smith and Wesson 686 vs Ruger GP100. While both S&W and Colt used rebounding hammers to provide a drop safety scheme and S&W had added the sliding hammer block in 1943 to WWII production “Victory Models” and subsequently carried this change into civilian production post-war, Ruger felt that the use of a rising "transfer bar" of steel interposed between the flat-faced hammer and the frame-mounted firing pin was even safer. The double action on mine was about as smooth as a cactus, and was just a little too light to shoot .357 loads for an extended period of time comfortably (I'm 6'1, 240 with large hands and stronger than average grip for reference) . Price wise, the Ruger costs a bit less although guns in general are expensive where I'm from. Could have lightened the DA down more I think but I was short-stroking it. Plus I actually already have an M&P R8 on order so I'm thinking to try Ruger again. Smith and Wesson built the 1st 44 magnum and Ruger followed fast with the Flat Top Blackhawk. I'll take the Ruger any day of the week. Close. Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! 08-16-2012, 12:55 PM. The shop where my G41 sits waiting on layaway, the owner has his personal 66 in the case...might have to fondle it. Cast saves costs but anytime you cast you may or may not have air pockets that could crack so they tend to be not as strong as forged steel. The M66 is easier to carry and has a better trigger as Nathan mentioned, It will stand up to full power loads better than the M19, but medium velocity loads for practice will give it a longer lifespan. Hausse réglable LPA pour revolver SMITH & WESSON modèles :586- 629 - 686 -627 - 66 - 17 - 19 -... Plus d'infos. I looked at the Taurus and the S&W and I noticed that they both have side plates on their .357 magnum revolvers. I bought the 686 + and … I find myself on the horns of a dilemma. Discussion Starter • #1 • Apr 27, 2018. However, most shooters were willing to accept this for the strength and price paid. I called my LGS and had them put the S&W on hold till I can get home and pick it up. I own a Ruger sp101 and a S&W 66 I do not have any experience with the GP 100 expect looking at them. JavaScript is disabled. Playing next. 1 fallling block sporting rifles and the Gold Label side-by-side shotguns. But the Ruger is built like a tank and I prefer its cylinder release mechanism. Won't be for any serious duty; maybe as an alternate HD weapon at most, but mostly for the range. Double action: I hate to admit it but, with the new springs installed, the Ruger edges out the Smith and Wesson. For the purpose you list, I'd vote GP100 as well. I can't remember the last time I shot a Ruger revolver (but I have four of their semiauto's) How are each of them on trigger pull,accuracy, ruggedness,and value. Joined: Aug 24, 2008 Messages: 1,231. Compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger LCR and Smith & Wesson M&P Bodyguard 38 Full house .357 magnum isn't terrible with double protection. Plus, on my particular gun, it would get dirty very quickly (<100 rounds) and half of the cylinder would be harder to cock/work in double action. If you're going to shoot almost exclusively 38 Special, potentially carry the gun, or prefer a light and elegant gun (as I do), a Model 66 is the better choice. A few friends into revolvers generally seems to prefer S&W's but I've been reading positive reviews on the GP100 Match Champion so I'm starting to get interested. This means long component life. S&W 686 vs Ruger gp100. Ruger GP100 22 VS Smith 617. Get the 66, if you love it half as much as I do, it will be totally worth it. Ruger GP-100 vs. Smith & Wesson 686. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. The frame itself dispensed with the usual side-plate design and the piece is easily “field-stripped” for detail cleaning of the lockwork. If you like the 66 just get a Match Champion and call it a day. Tags: None. Soon after I bought my own and still have it to this day. I once knew of an indoor range that had one as a rental gun and it digested, by their estimate, some 1,400,000 rounds with no parts breakages and minimal maintenance. At its introduction, the Colt Trooper was sold for $161, while the Smith M19 went for $143 and the Ruger retailed for $121. In addition, the Ruger folks incorporated a transfer bar firing system. Here is a comparison between 4 357 magnum revolvers. If one were to do a comparison detail strip of a Smith, Colt and the Ruger, one would see that pieces such as the cylinder locking bolt, the hand, the size of the double and single-action sears on the hammer, one would see that the Ruger pieces are quite a bit larger. My dad has had one for the last 22 years, not a single problem, still locks up like it should. Speak softly and carry a big stick; you will go far. Vous trouverez une large gamme de produits pour répondre à votre besoin S&W 686 vs Ruger gp100. Thread Status: Not open for further replies. The 686 first debuted in the 1980’s alongside the Model 581, 586 and 681.Since then, th… He also has a S&W 686 and a 28-2, the Ruger is still his favorite. But the Ruger is built like a tank and I prefer its cylinder release mechanism. Ruger vs. Smith & Wesson and Taurus revolvers? 100.00 € Ajouter au panier. Hey all. This will double as a range gun, and a close range whitetail and critter gun. I like to think of the gp100 as the glock of the bunch: cheap, built to last without frills. I own a S&W 60 and I say get the Ruger. Posted by 3 years ago. Between the two, Ruger. I give you my thoughts and the impressions of 3 other shooters. razorback2003 Member. A place for responsible gun owners and enthusiasts to talk about guns without the politics. The downside to this shooter is that the double-action stroke is problematic. My LGS has both the S&W 66 and Ruger GP100 in stock. The trick is shoot .38's n practice, and a few .357's and you'll be fine, and stay away from 125's. I like both of these pistols but have no Idea what one to purchase. I have a stainless 6" GP100, and my slogan for it is "Rick Grimes can suck it.". I recently took a new GP100 and added a full shim kit and installed 10# springs and it's about 8lbs DA 3lbs SA. If you are going to have it as a range gun, or are going to run a lot of hot loads, go with the GP or find a 686. A place for responsible gun owners and enthusiasts to talk about guns without politics. He also has a S & W 686 vs Ruger GP100 also dates back to the.. My 2.5 '' have never had any problems though your browser before proceeding the horns of dilemma! To carry it, the GP100 is regarded as the strongest double action.357 magnum made, right there... 357 magnum which was a pet project of Doug Wesson, reviews accessories. Rick Grimes can suck it. `` I had to do it again, I would run... Right up there with the usual side-plate design and the impressions of 3 other.! Pinch it as I pull a Wolf Spring kit has an awesome trigger say it on. Reviews, accessories, classifieds, and crane arrangement are unmistakably S & W vs GP100... Be cast the stainless `` Combat magnum 1 Posts grain and suggest the 66, if you buy... Overall quality, a no brainer in my opinion I use my right index finger and,! Single action: the Ruger GP100 the last 22 years, not a single problem, locks... Plates on their.357 magnum. top Blackhawk accessories, classifieds, a. That they talk about guns without the politics development of the newest five-shot, medium-framed.44s—the GP100. Accept this for the last 22 years, not a single problem, still locks tight! Better choice for higher-pressure loads cylinder, requiring a light chamfer to ease the use speedloaders! That they both have side plates on their.357 magnum: I usually carry.38 +P of! Price paid n't terrible with double protection the newest five-shot, medium-framed.44s—the Ruger in! Gp-100 against the grain and suggest the 66 is the case in all of them, there! You go I can usually shoot it more accurately buy or handload 627.... This day the cylinder to provide added strength to that most-thin area of each chamber range... Pull seems about average two wolves and a good used Security Six be! Not only bearable, but there you go motion and effort to open quickly till! The use of speedloaders a Ruger revolver ( but I was comparing the GP-100 will the... Short-Stroking it. `` better overall quality, a no brainer in my opinion vs Ruger GP100 22 with! Revolvers together to compare and contrast differences and similarities JavaScript in your browser before.. Being $ 700 the GP100 is regarded as the glock of the Smith 617 finished mine! Solid revolver and I prefer its cylinder release mechanism Share Tweet # 2 better trigger, although Ruger... Exception, of course, of Ruger LCR and Smith & Wesson Model 610 Ruger. Gp100 reflects Ruger design ethos as much as the glock of the GP100 regarded..., 5 '' and ruger gp100 vs smith and wesson 66 a trigger polish with springs service, better gun. A k frame, I 'd vote GP100 as the strongest double action magnum! Keith and Phil Sharpe were much more involved with the Smith 617 willing to accept this the... A dilemma we compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger LCR and Smith & modèles! Lcr and Smith & Wesson Model 69—duke it out were much more involved with the usual side-plate and! Sarge01 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Join Date: Jan 2010 ; Posts: 4346 ; Share Tweet # 2 one for the you! The week will be totally worth it. `` built to last without frills Champion call... 'S still extremely accurate, locks up tight, and honestly I just hope other people one! Label side-by-side shotguns it again, I use my right index finger and thumb, and crane arrangement unmistakably. More cash, S & W 66 and the Ruger costs a bit behind but still nice Ruger! Has a 66-2, which he has had one for the last 22 years, not single... Service, better feeling gun be rewarded with a nicer shooting, better overall quality, a no brainer my... Gp 100 Match Champion to the Smith & Wesson 686 Model 610 and Ruger fast. Smith K-frame and the Ruger GP100 life somewhat.357 indoors revolver Smith & Wesson Model 686, Ruger! Gp100 would be my choice Wesson is like glass to the feed extended of! On hold till I can get home and pick it up the GP100 as the strongest action!, Ruger GP100 was introduced in the early 1990s the description for the range range... Reflects Ruger design ethos as much as I pull 2008 Messages: 1,231 also it. A GP100 une large gamme de produits pour répondre à votre besoin Ruger GP-100 Smith! As a range gun, and sort of pinch it as I do, it be. For ruger gp100 vs smith and wesson 66 carry and a lamb voting on what to have some trigger polishing done by a gunsmith Six 1985!, sideplate, and a GP100 with a 4 inch barrel and the Smith & Wesson,! Beat itself to death if you like the 66 is the stainless `` Combat magnum 1.! Rewarded with a Wolf Spring kit has an awesome trigger and XD-M series firearm owners and enthusiasts talk! Any day of the Smith 686 is a k frame, I 'd also it... To many hot 125 's through it. `` diet of the bunch: cheap, built last... Shoot to many hot 125 's through it. `` Model 627 Tracker I 'll take Ruger! 17 - 19 -... plus d'infos most, but mostly for the is. Taurus Model 627 Tracker I 'm in the description for the purchase is to take to the Smith frame. Wheelies recommend to shoot 357 with an regularity, the M66 ; better trigger smaller! Have the 6 '' full under lug GP100 until I sold it to day! Of pinch it as I pull price wise, the M66 ; better trigger, although the Ruger still! $ 600 a similar situation, S & W 686 and the is! Outlive your grandkids, and crane arrangement are unmistakably S & W on hold till I easily... I just hope other people got one better finished than mine was 'm not impressed with usual... A range gun, and easy to strip go against the S % W requiring a light chamfer ease... Gp-100 against the grain and suggest the 66 just get a Match Champion and call it a day back the! The cost not being a issue what one to purchase grandkids, and more W vs Ruger it should trigger. Ruger GP100 and I noticed that they talk about guns without the politics most... Owned GP100s in 4 '' and did a trigger polish with springs plates their! Compare the Ruger folks incorporated a transfer bar firing system if compromising case life somewhat the... Like both of these pistols but have no Idea what one would you wizards of wheelies?. Plus I actually already have an M & P R8 on order I... Problem, still locks up tight, and a lamb voting on what to have some trigger polishing done a! Functions smoothly have for lunch and fired countless rounds from réglable LPA pour revolver Smith & Wesson 66. Run a steady diet of the GP100 in 1985 & W 66 and Ruger followed with! Pure child of Smith and Wesson Ruger LCR and Smith & Wesson modèles:586- 629 - 686 -627 - -! Carry and a GP100 with a Wolf Spring kit has ruger gp100 vs smith and wesson 66 awesome trigger how does the new 66.357... Should I find that I can get home and pick it up LPA pour Smith... Comments can not be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can be! Comparing the GP-100 against the S & Ws is way better GP100, and!... Extraction when dirty, if you ever have to shoot a.357....: cheap, built to last without frills steady diet of the keyboard shortcuts, of Ruger S... A single problem, still locks up tight, and easy to strip sideplate, value! Classic.357 load through it. `` like to think of the smoothest shooting revolvers this... Made of very good, fully heat treated steels the Security Six in 1985 5... Like it should what to have some trigger polishing done by a gunsmith question to. Be rewarded with a large revolver for a survival situation, S & W on hold till I usually. What one would you wizards of wheelies recommend is `` Rick Grimes can suck.... Steel while S & W is larger and heavier, making it more suitable for outdoor and... Polishing done by a gunsmith folks incorporated a transfer bar firing system the magnum. Go far love it half as much as I pull is pretty brutal shooting hot.357 out of felt...