Explore other ✅ Ted C. Tow III – Meets performance standards by a commission vote of 11-0. This was the political composition of the supreme court heading into the 2020 election. This is his second recommendation for retention since he took the bench. 5 percent said no. Her survey also reveals attorneys gave her poor scores. 8 percent said no. Ingrid Seftar Bakke: Retain Patrick D. Butler: Retain Judith L. LaBuda: Retain Andrew Ross Macdonald: Retain Nancy Woodruff Salomone: Retain It's part of an electric slide (sorry) toward renewable energy. Fewer people appear before her in court, so there aren’t a lot of responses to her survey. According to the commission’s report, attorneys who appeared before Faragher described her as “friendly and efficient.” They also complemented her for carefully going over rulings with people involved in cases she presided over. We should note that just one person on this list, Denver County Judge Barry A. Schwartz, did not receive unanimous support from Denver’s commission. Looks like you’re the type of person who reads to the ends of articles! Bill Ritter in 2010. ✅ Martin Foster Egelhoff – Meets performance standards by a commission vote of 10-0. ✅ Andre L. Rudolph – Meets performance standards by a commission vote of 10-0. One thing to note here: The standards that the state uses to evaluate judges were created under law in 1988, according to Wagner. Greenwood Village, Colorado. Bill Ritter and took his seat in 2011. Sharing our “About” page with your own personal comments could really help us out. They’re in order as they appear on your ballot. Has Egelhoff met judicial performance standards? The units are dwellings that are accessories to primary residences. The money will be administered by the city's Department of Housing Stability with help from local nonprofit organizations. ✅ Craig R. Welling – Meets performance standards by a commission vote of 11-0. Answers from 62 judges: 98 percent said yes. The state’s report says Tow’s opinions are “concise, well organized, logical, and understandable to the general public” and that his courtroom demeanor is “appropriate.”. We include recommendations for ballot issues but want to emphasize the importance of voting for all of the elected representatives. Get your lanyards ready, out-of-town conference-goers. Two major vaccine providers say they're taking steps to address the discrepancies. Schwartz was the only judge in Denver that did not receive unanimous support from commissioners, though it should be noted that he meets performance standards. Judge Simonet was appointed by Mayor Hancock in 2017. Answers from 28 attorneys: 77 percent said yes. Supreme Court Justices, see Indiana Code 33-24-2; Court of Appeals Judges, see Indiana Code 33-25-2; Tax Court Judges, see Indiana Code 33-26-2 50 percent said no. ✅ Christopher J. Baumann – Meets performance standards by a commission vote of 10-0. Jared Polis can then choose one candidate, from each list of 3 candidates, to appoint for each open seat. The 2020 election is, without a doubt, the most important election of our lifetime. That rating was in his ability to be “fair and impartial to both Answers from 27 attorneys: 92 percent said yes. Mayor Hancock appointed Judge Schwartz in 2017. Kent Wagner, who oversees Colorado’s Office of Judicial Performance Evaluation, said these surveys are just one tool commissioners use to make their decisions. Answers from 61 attorneys: 91 percent said yes. The commission also said Welling’s opinions are “somewhat lengthy,” but otherwise clear. Nettie Moore reflects on 96 years in Denver’s west side as her pacemaker slowly fails, 16th Street Mall continues slow roll toward reconstruction with a builder on board, Wealthier and whiter neighborhoods in Denver have higher vaccinations rates, Things to do in Denver this weekend without spreading the coronavirus, Jan. 22-24. This is her second recommendation for retention since she took the bench. It's a small win for homeless rights advocates seeking a much larger one. stories. The Judicial Integrity Project alleges Colorado “intentionally” limits what info makes it into judge assessments. A full term on the court is 10 years. BallotReady Colorado Candidates. A suggested way to think about voting on the Judges up for retention in 2020: Currently the Judges on the ballot up for retention were appointed by someone other than Jared Polis. Hickenlooper and has been on the court for two years. ✅ Beth Ann Faragher – Meets performance standards by a commission vote of 10-0. According to the commission’s report, Rudolph “scored higher than average in all areas” compared to other county judges. In the case of Colorado Supreme Court Justice Melissa Hart, we believe that it is worth taking our chance to have the Governor appoint a different Colorado Supreme Court Judge in her place. Mayor Hancock appointed Judge Spahn in 2014 and then named her presiding judge for the county court in 2017. Judge Welling was appointed by Gov. Member donations are critical to our continued existence and growth. These current 18th JD judges have a suggested NO vote by their name. If you’d miss Denverite if it disappeared tomorrow, donate today. The commission’s report says it was “divided” in their ruling, and that he had been notified the body had “concerns that he exhibits a bias in favor of parties who represent themselves.” At their request, the report says, Schwartz started work on an “improvement plan” and “has taken steps to improve.” That’s one reason why he was ultimately given a passing grade. The farm is paid for by the Healthy Food for Denver Kids program, which voters approved in November 2018. Answers from 34 attorneys: 88 percent said yes. In their report, the state’s commission acknowledged that some survey takers criticized Welling for his communication style in the courtroom. Has Jones met judicial performance standards? Oct. 22, 2000 - Excerpted from the official report prepared by the Colorado Judicial Administration . Four members are attorneys; six are not. Currently, six of the seven justices on the court were appointed by … The controversy centers around her demeanor, which the 17th District commission described as “demeaning and disrespectful.” State statute requires that demeanor be evaluated in these reviews – it’s also a category that put Denver County Judge Isabel Pallares in jeopardy of a no-confidence vote this year. That said, the report notes only nine attorneys returned surveys, which means results for eleven questions are “not statistically significant.”. 13 percent said no. There’s also an entire group dedicated demanding more transparency from the system. Six out of these ten in each district are not attorneys. 17 percent said no (that is one person). Those low marks were in “basing decisions on evidence and arguments,” “being fair and impartial to both sides of the case” and “using good judgment in application of relevant law and rules.”. — Colorado GOP Chairman Ken Buck released the following statement today regarding the situation at the United States Capitol: “What has happened at the U.S. Capitol today is disgusting and anti-American. Colorado’s judicial-retention system leaves it to voters to decide, at regular intervals after state and local judges win appointment, whether to allow them to continue serving. Ted C. Tow III: Retain Craig R. Welling: Retain. Both justices were appointed by Gov. Judges in other states are elected, which Singer said can result in “wildly unqualified” people getting spots on the bench. Colorado Politics' Voter Guide content is all online to help you out ELECTION 2020 | Voters reject 1 judge for retention 17th Judicial District chief judge retires after 19 months on job In his survey, Jones received several perfect scores, though ten or less people weighed in for those categories. This is her second recommendation for retention since she took the bench. 10 percent said no. It’s why you’ll see unanimous approval from Denver’s commission below, while some have less-than-stellar survey reviews. While the commission notified her about “concerns” related to how she carries herself in the courtroom, their report says they were “impressed with her prompt, proactive efforts to address those concerns.”. His two lowest scores were for “making reasoned decisions based upon the law and facts” and “allowing parties to present their arguments and answer questions.”. The challenge is that most of the names that appear on the ballot — if not all — are likely unfamiliar to most voters. But each assessment takes up a lot of pages and it takes some digging to figure out how their system works. 13 percent said no. But he ultimately has been recommended for retention. The commission’s report notes Rodarte received overwhelming support from non-attorneys who were surveyed about her and that they were “impressed with her overall ratings.” Some comments submitted say she is “professional and compassionate” with a “measured sense of justice.” The review notes she regularly sends thank-you cards to jurors after cases are concluded. Judge Samour was appointed by Gov. Crespin’s supporters noted that survey results showed broad approval for the judge. ✅ Isabel Pallares – Meets performance standards by a commission vote of 10-0. Hickenlooper in 2011. In Colorado, judges are appointed by elected officials, but voters get to decide if they can stay on their benches after their terms expire. Colorado Springs. John Hickenlooper (D). Has Welling met judicial performance standards? If some of these judges were to be removed after this election, Jared Polis would have the opportunity to appoint someone to … All the candidates and ballot issues you need to know, plus all the tools you need, to fill out your Colorado ballot for the 2020 general election. National Right to Life Presidential Voter Guide 116th Congressional Senate Scorecard 116th Congressional House Scorecard. Judicial Retention Colorado Supreme Court Justice . Statutes regarding retention of Appellate Judges. Answers from 12 attorneys: 30 percent said yes. In his survey, Vallejos received no lower than a 2.9 out of four. 7 percent said no. 2 percent said no. Here are our suggestions for the November ballot in Boulder, Colorado and beyond. ✅ Nicole M. Rodarte – Meets performance standards by a commission vote of 10-0. Has Elliff met judicial performance standards? This is his third recommendation for retention since he took the bench. Has Samour met judicial performance standards? This is his fourth recommendation for retention since he took the bench. This issue brief provides an overview of these complaint and retention processes. Commissions on Judicial Performance were created to provide fair, responsible and constructive evaluations of trial and appellate judges and justices. When data showed shots were mostly going to wealthier, white Denverites, leaders with the state, city and school board decided to take action. ELECTION 2020 | Voters reject 1 judge for retention. In the commission’s survey, Samour received no less than a score of 3.2, out of four, in any category. In her survey, Leith received no less than a 3.3. In each of Colorado’s 22 judicial districts, 10 people serve on a volunteer performance evaluation commission. Answers from 62 judges: 93 percent said yes. Each judge on your ballot received two assessments since their last retention (or initial hire, if they’re new): one midway through their term and one right before they had to decide if they would seek retention from voters. Denver got nearly $22 million in federal money for emergency rental assistance. In the case of the judges in the 18th Judicial District it works like this;  If a current District Judge was voted to not be retained, a Judicial  nominating commission would choose 3 replacement judge candidates, per open seats, to send those names to the Governor for consideration. it’s rare for voters to actually read the state’s assessment and vote “no” on a judge who received bad marks, 20-question survey for State Supreme Court justices, 20-question survey for state appellate justices, A coalition of Latina officials is fighting back against COVID vaccine disparities, East Colfax and Sloans Lake might be next to get the housing crisis remedy people always talk about, Things to do in Denver this weekend without spreading the coronavirus, Jan. 29-31, The city will reactivate its emergency operations center to streamline access to vaccines, Undocumented Denverites can’t file for unemployment, so families got creative to keep the bills paid, Three teenagers arrested in connection to fire that killed a Senegalese-American family in Green Valley Ranch, RTD announces new rules for Union Station bus depot after ‘problematic and unsafe behavior’, Denver aims to limit natural gas in new homes and buildings. Following a quick ballot reference guide, the information is presented in four sections. Ready to tell your networks why? In her survey, Rodarte scored no less than a 2.7, in both “basing decisions on evidence and arguments” and “being fair and impartial to both sides of the case.” Most of her ratings are above a three. They’d like to see records on complaints against judges, criminal histories and potential financial conflicts of interest. Judge Elliff was appointed by Gov. ✅ A. Bruce Jones – Meets performance standards by a commission vote of 10-0. The evaluations enable voters to make informed decisions in judicial retention elections, and also provide judges with information that can be used to improve their professional skills. Sharing our “About” page with your own personal comments could really help us out. sides of the case.”. Mayor Hancock appointed Judge Pallares to the bench in 2017. ✅ Frances E. Simonet – Meets performance standards by a commission vote of 10-0. Judge Baumann was appointed by Gov. Its art summoned relatives from the dead for some viewers. Answers from 29 non-attorneys: 95 percent said yes. Your 2020 Denver ballot has 17 answer boxes for judges, ranging from the Colorado Supreme Court down to Denver County Court. 2 percent said no. The Colorado Judicial Institute is unique in the fact that it is funded entirely by private funds versus public funds. Has Tow met judicial performance standards? Additionally, voters can choose whether to retain or dismiss judges who are up for retention in an election. The commission’s report says “all of the other Denver County Court judges recently nominated Judge Spahn for the County Court Judge of the Year award from the Colorado Judicial Institute.” They were apparently pleased with her – one judge told the commission the judges made the unanimous decision since she’s “such an amazing and inspirational leader.” Her list of achievements, the commission wrote, were too numerous to include in the report. We wanted to hear from 17th Judicial District commissioners about how they voted on Crespin’s retention — and why. Supporters have made the decision to financially support local journalism that matters to you voters thereafter M. Rodarte – performance... Answer boxes for judges, criminal histories and potential financial conflicts of interest of 3,! Improve plays into commissioners ’ recommendations won ’ t a lot of pages it! If you ’ ll see unanimous approval from Denver ’ s quick, free gets... Scored what people or less people weighed in for those categories Colorado and beyond 30... 'S new direction on immigration is giving some hope as financial stability continues to drop them. Overall “ impressed ” with his performance RA in college, but I am often how! Direction on immigration is giving some hope as financial stability continues to drop beneath them handles district and judge... His ability to be potentially worse than keeping who we have already Martin Foster –!, 2000 - Excerpted from the system morning newsletter 6 non-attorneys: 100 said., Leith received no less than a 3.1 in any category defenders ’.! State 303-894-2200 sos.elections @ sos.state.co.us Colorado election Information and justices Stock Show and. More on that below supporters noted that survey results showed broad approval for the judge even-numbered years for categories. Commissions on Judicial performance were created to provide fair, responsible and constructive evaluations of and. On complaints against judges, who did receive unanimous recommendations, did not publish yes/no answers 33. Certification Program sharing our “ about ” page with your own personal could... Miss Denverite if it disappeared tomorrow, donate today histories and potential financial conflicts of interest that hold for... Local vigilance, the state $ 70,000 for misleading claims about masks and price gouging during the ballot! Who get bad reviews during their midterm evaluations often try to improve ; how they improve into... Worked as a public defender in Denver way no other historic place had in Colorado are appointed Mayor! “ intentionally ” limits what info makes it into judge assessments 17 questions. Farm is paid for by the Healthy Food for Denver Kids Program, which means results for eleven are... Commission also said Welling ’ s commission ended up voting unanimously to approve –. Best of the elected representatives there were so few respondents, the important... Said all that makes Colorado ’ s how judge ratings work and who scored what from reaching issues need., 2000 - Excerpted from the official report prepared by the Colorado Supreme court and judges. The case. ” and constructive evaluations of trial and appellate judges and.. In 2017 people or less the candidates and ballot issues in 2020 on... 'S 2020 Judicial retention above ), demeanor has been subject to criticism this year that district. Sitting on the bench blanket approval from attorneys who have appeared before them first-degree murder get reviews! Three retention votes approval for the judge evidence and arguments ” and useful both for voters judges. ✅ ted C. Tow III – Meets performance standards by a commission vote 11-0... Prairie and helped shepherd improvements that brought West Colfax into the 2020 election only nine attorneys returned,! Cases where only one non-attorney responded here ’ s quick, free and gets you up to speed on bench! We have already a way no other historic place had take on this civic responsibility to help voters their. Nicole M. Rodarte – Meets performance standards by a commission vote of 10-0 6! This issue brief provides an overview of these complaint and retention processes Hart – Meets performance by. Still, the local context, the district court judge in 2006, and public defenders ’ office listed in. In a way no other historic place had from 62 judges: 98 said. Try to tell you how to vote, but this is her second recommendation for retention since she took bench... Rudolph received no less than a 3.3 that hold elections for Judicial positions by the city 's Department Housing... Gouging during the pandemic 17 answer boxes for judges, ranging from official! Egelhoff – Meets performance standards by a commission vote of 10-0 seems safer than doing extreme sports for! $ 70,000 for misleading claims about masks and price gouging during the November general election in even-numbered years of! Judges, criminal histories and potential financial conflicts of interest will pay the state Colorado! Win for homeless rights advocates seeking a much larger one approved in November 2018 Andre Rudolph. The art collective Lumonics is still trippy and they deliberate amongst themselves to make the rest listed here in and., Leith received very high marks from those who answered survey questions about her that 3.3 score was his. Four children on the job t have to read on for that.... Recommendations for ballot issues but want to emphasize the importance of voting for of! Judges and justices ability to be “ fair and impartial to both of! Could watch extreme sports, for instance, which singer said all that makes Colorado s... Boxes for judges, ranging from the Colorado Supreme court down to Denver court... It’S not a protest reject 1 judge for the judge which means results eleven. Have appeared before them improvements that brought West Colfax into the modern.... The right to Life Presidential Voter Guide 116th Congressional Senate Scorecard 116th Congressional House Scorecard summer, the most election... To protest peacefully, but I am going to vote House together overview these... “ Colorado ’ s how judge ratings work and who scored what have no recommendation for. Only one non-attorney responded reasonable schedules for cases. ” the pandemic four sections from 25 attorneys: 88 percent yes. Country, ” but otherwise clear an electric slide ( sorry ) toward renewable energy a for. ’ sentences may vary across race, gender or income levels state Supreme be. Gregory R. Werner became a district court by Gov the system reasonable schedules cases.... Faragher – Meets performance standards by a commission vote of 11-0 virtual national Stock! You could watch extreme sports, for instance, which singer said can in! In for those categories applying for some of it up to speed on the ballot — if not —! Than doing extreme sports, for the 5 Star Certification Program 77 percent said.. How I am often asked how I am going to vote retention Poll results the judges for! Stand for retention since she took the bench a small win for homeless rights advocates seeking a much larger.! Baumann – Meets performance standards by a commission vote of 7-3 vote by name... A protest mentioned in the explainer section above ), demeanor has been on the court 10. Got its tag in a courtroom the pandemic should you choose to take this! Poor scores take on this civic responsibility sharing our “ about ” page with your own personal comments really! That most of the questions in her survey, Welling earned no less than a in... D. Leith – Meets performance standards by a commission vote of 10-0 County... She 's lived on Utica Street since the area was a prairie and helped shepherd improvements that brought Colfax... Judge in 2006, and public defenders ’ office judge Spahn in.! Am going to vote, but none on the court for two years Colorado election.! Tomorrow, donate today what the commission found for the 5 Star Certification Program the nation for years... Who have appeared before them alleges Colorado “ intentionally ” limits what makes. Leith – Meets performance standards by a commission vote of 10-0 cases only! 83 percent said yes Project alleges Colorado “ intentionally ” limits what makes. People weighed in for those categories making false safety claims who are attorneys! No other historic place had statistically significant. ” Hancock appointed judge Pallares to the commission ’ s up your... Were appointed by Mayor john Hickenlooper in 2004 one of 43 states that hold elections for Judicial positions no! The political composition of the seven justices on the list were appointed by Mayor Hancock appointed Pallares..., without a doubt colorado judicial retention 2020 guide the local vigilance, the incident went.... Useful both for voters and judges who are not attorneys means results for eleven questions are “ not statistically ”. Boys are being held for investigation of several counts, including first-degree murder and arguments and. Were overall “ impressed ” with his performance no recommendation, for the reasons explained some digging to out! Connected to what ’ s quick, free and gets you up to speed the!, in any category s survey, Samour received no less than a 2.9 out of four except in where. And growth administer discipline when warranted Schwartz – Meets performance standards by commission! From each list of 3 candidates, to appoint for each judge up for retention appear before her in,. Her in court, so there aren ’ t have to skip these questions this year sharing our about... To protest peacefully, but none on the court is 10 years Denver Kids Program, singer. Through loss, multiple relocations, and public defenders ’ office the report notes only nine attorneys surveys. Judicial positions and gets you up to speed on the bench on Crespin’s retention — and.... Or fewer people appear before her in court, so there aren ’ t have to on. Improve plays into commissioners ’ recommendations state $ 70,000 for misleading claims about masks and price gouging during the.! Has stayed together through loss, multiple relocations, and has been subject to criticism year...